Weekend Sun   

Tsunami sirens back on the agenda

Straight from city council
A personal view,
by Councillor Steve Morris

Next year you will have the opportunity to choose between two types of siren for council to warn you during a civil defence emergency (including tsunami).

Our staff are beavering away on getting the likely costs and coverage by February to help us make an informed decision.

The first option is for rates-funded outdoor electronic sirens which will be fixed on poles like they have been in some Christchurch and Auckland suburbs. Early estimates indicate these may cost $2.5m to install.

The second option involves in-home sirens (working a bit like a smoke alarm); early estimates indicate a $500,000 to $1.8 million installation cost which could be partly funded via rates, or totally user-pays. We could even consider a mix of both outdoor and indoor options.

The chief benefits of both these systems is that they can deliver voice instructions as well as an alerting tone.

However, my preference has always been for outdoor air-raid sirens because they are a tried and true (think WWII) method of warning and have lower ongoing maintenance costs over the decades. Unfortunately, this third option didn't gain the support of a majority of councillors; largely because government is trying to have a consistent ‘national standard' for tsunami sirens around the country.

Cr Bill Grainger and I aren't satisfied that air-raid sirens have been excluded from consideration so things could change, but like anything in council, you need a majority.

Keep in mind any sirens will be in addition to a text message system that government is working on.

Comments


So Steve, are you telling us?

Posted on 24-08-2017 19:52 | By Papamoaner

That the loud air raid sirens we all heard and most of us want, are not even considered? NOBODY LISTENS TO THE PEOPLE!

What about the elderly

Posted on 22-08-2017 12:48 | By joan king

Through all of these topics they talk about text messages. Tauranga in particular has many elderly people living here who don't have fancy mobile phones due to the cost of not only purchasing them but the ongoing costs involved each month. I dont have one and dont need one so for others like me and my husband (and I am sure there are many) wouldnt receive a text message. Something loud is important especially for the hard of hearing as well. I am sure the council tends to think they are old and in the minority and dont matter. Understandable maybe. I have accepted if there was a Tsunami that I would probably drown in it. Many couldnt get away on foot anyway. We all have to die of something.

What happened to the sirens that used to be...

Posted on 21-08-2017 09:50 | By GreertonBoy

on the poles? There was one up the pole in Chadwick rd opposite the post orifice? I still think that a helicopter mounted siren, not unlike a police car siren would be the way to go. Electronic sirens can make any noise, so if police cars, fire engines and ambulances had the 'siren sound' required in their sirens repertoir... in the event of a tsunami, they can all switch to 'that' siren sound... the rescue helicopter or other helicopters could have access to siren units they could fly around designated areas that are likely to be effected. I bet the Chinese could make a small siren that can pump out 150Db for about $20? No need to spend $zillions buying some fantastic system (supposedly) that will likely be outdated in 5 years... Oh, councils have endless cash supply, I forgot. Silly me

Still waiting

Posted on 20-08-2017 20:38 | By Captain Sensible

Why don't you answer the question Steve? Why should us ratepayers pay for your meals? You seem to talk the talk but do not walk the walk. Save money yadda yadda yadda....but then expect us to pay for your meals. Why do we ratepayers pay to fill your trough?

Simple. Reverse the desicuon. Ask Molloy and Baldock how.

Posted on 19-08-2017 20:18 | By Murray.Guy

Elected members made their decision based on inadequate, misleading and false information. That in itself is grounds. Bit like the promise that likely wasn't.

Those big ones

Posted on 19-08-2017 19:30 | By Papamoaner

Those big sirens with the huge horns were THUNDEROUS when you demonstrated them a few years ago. The others all seemed like toys. Why waste money?



Post a Comment

You must be logged in to make a comment.